Dear Robin, I'm buying genealogy books slowly. My copy of John Littell's "Family Records or Genealogies of the First Settlers of the Passaic Valley" came in the mail yesterday. I was looking through it for the ~third~ time, and found on pp. 68-70: James CAULDWELL/Mary GASTON *James' children by Mary: 1. *William Cauldwell/Elizabeth Thompson both from Ireland 1732 2. Robert Cauldwell/_____ 3. Hugh Cauldwell/Jane Parker 4. Abraham Cauldwell/Catherine Hill 5. James Cauldwell/Peggy ____ 6. John Cauldwell 7. Jennet Cauldwell/----- Miller ->8. Sarah CAULDWELL/Isaac ROLL <-------------------------My line William's children by Elizabeth 1. Aaron Cauldwell 2. James Cauldwell/Elizabeth Cauldwell 3. *John Cauldwell/Hannah Rutan 4. Mary Cauldwell/Nathaiel Littell 5. Moses Cauldwell 6. Sarah Cauldwell/Isarel Cory 7. Robert Cauldwell/Mary Ball 8. Elizabeth Cauldwell/Alexander Simpson 9. Dan Cauldwell/Rachel Potter 10. Abraham Cauldwell/Elizabeth Rutan John's children by Hannah 1. Rachel Cauldwell 2. John Cauldwell/Eleca Hand 3. Abraham Rutan Cauldwell/Electa Johnson /2. Aquilla Berry 4. Hugh Cauldwell d. 14 Nov 1822/Abigail Gibbs 5. Peter Rutan Cauldwell/Lecinah Fitch 6. *Robert M. Cauldwell/Betsy Cauldwell 7. Jerry Cauldwell/Mary Eliza Boyer Hugh's children by Abigail: 1. Jane Cauldwell b. 25 Oct 1812/Daniel Trembly ------->2. *Robert Cauldwell b. 05 Nov 1816/m. 16 May 1841 Julia Anne MARSH, ------------>daughter of Gideon MARSH of Westfield, ------------>live in Elizabethtown... 3. Hannah Maria Cauldwell b. 25 Dec 1818 4. William McDowel Cauldwell 5. Elizabeth Cauldwell Robert's children by Julia: 1. Freeman Cauldwell 2. George Cauldwell Could this be your Gideon MARSH? Do you have Littell's book. If Not, I can send copies of the pages, if you don't. -Bill _________________________________________________________________ William Henry Roll Blythe, California [email protected] The Roll Family Genealogy Windmill http://members.aol.com/whroll The genealogy of the ROLL, MANGEL and VAN WOGGELUM families "A thousand candles have burned themselves out; yet I read on."