Hi Kathy, Did you get my page 4? This was Isaac Roll & Sarah Cauldwell. If you didn't, I can send it again. Compare it with your research and if there are any difference, let me know. I have child # 2, Mary & child # 3, Catherine Baptised on the same day suggesting that they might have been twins, but Mary died young. I also have a Julia A. Woodruff b. 1847 d. 1946. She is listed under Catherine Roll & Abner Woodruff but it's not possible that she was their child because Catherine died 1838. I can't find her as a granddaughter either but I don't have the information on every child. All this will be in Hansel's offer to all of you. I encourage you to get that. He has made a very generous offer to everyone and I will try to fill in what is missing from his pages too. Let me know about P. 4. Martha