This is the N.J. Family. There are two John Eddy Roll's. I believe this one is who the articles refer to, according to the names of his children. They were: William V. Roll, Frank Palmer Roll, & John Linden Roll. John Roll & Elizabeth Sickles Isaac Roll & Sarah Cauldwell John Roll & Mary Earl William Roll & Mary Eddy John Eddy Roll & (1) Harriet Van Dyke, (2) Sarah A. (Mosalauder) Case The other John Eddy Roll: John Roll & Elizabeth Sickles Isaac Roll & Sarah Cauldwell John Roll & Mary Earl William Roll & Mary Eddy Alpheus Pierson Roll & Mary Evan Mosalauder John Eddy Roll & (1) Phoebe D. Roll (2) Catherine (Theobald) Schuster Children by 1st wife, Phoebe D. Roll 1. Nellie P. Roll 2. Josephine Roll Children by 2nd wife, Catherine (Theobald) Schuster 3. Roy Linden Roll (this is the one who's records were destroyed) 4. Lillian Mae Roll This Phoebe D. (Roll) Roll fits in: John Roll & Elizabeth Sickles Isaac Roll & Sarah Cauldwell Jacob C. Roll & Sarah Pierson Pierson Roll & 2nd wife, Catherine Spencer Phoebe D. Roll & John Eddy Roll I hope this isn't confusing. Martha