kate, what city did they live in and where did you get the baptismal records?. I checked the 1880 census on <A HREF="www.famiklysearch.org">www.famiklysearch.org</A> for each of the children but found nothing that matches. Perhaps the 1870 census for Ohio would yield something. Perhaps if you had an initial for Robert it would narrow him down in the 1880 census. Ever one listed on the 1880 census had a househiold list attached so you can be sure you have a right family. Sorry I couldn't be more help. Maybe you can make an inquery on a Ohio Newletter through Rootsweb. Did you find any school records for the children in Ohio? We have an IRISH IN ST. LOUIS MAIL LIST which is very helpful, perhaps you can find one in Ohio. Did Robert die - if so, when and where.? Rosemary Tooey