Melinda's dob was not the same as Polina's, according to Lenore Roblee's manuscript. Melinda was born 10 Feb 1793; Polina was born 15 Mar 1795. So, that part appears to be an error. Willim Case, first husband of Polina Robblee, was born on 5 Jul 1788 in Hebron, Washington Co., NY. He was the son of Abraham Case and Ruth Preston. Abraham was supposedly from Berkshire Co., MA. I took a glance at the Lanesborough History, just for fun, but didn't see Cases mentioned. Or Prestons for that matter. I find a William Utter, son of Joseph Utter and Margaret Dowty, b. abt 1765-- this was a KY man. I also find a William Burke Utter, b. 1803 in Ohio who married Malinda, or Mahala Truitt. He was son of Joseph Utter and Elizabeth Burke. He died in IN. His wife was born 1807 in KY. I looked at Susan Goss Johnston's data on the Desc. of Philip Case in Worldconnect (cited below as zacathan@comcast.net. As far as I can see, she does not know the first name of the Mr. Utter who married Melinda Roblee. So, I an confused -- and not ready to identify Melinda's husband as William Burke Utter. Cindy Walcotdt -----Original Message----- From: roblee-bounces@rootsweb.com [mailto:roblee-bounces@rootsweb.com]On Behalf Of Theresa Caparco Sent: Saturday, February 24, 2007 4:47 AM To: Cindy Waldron Subject: [ROBLEE] Melinda Roblee's huband, Utter Hello Everyone, First let me start off by finishing up on Polina Roblee: She married 1st-William Case...2nd- William Blair in 1832. Polina was born: 15 Mar. 1795 Granville, NY. died: 5 June 1851 Constantine, St. Joseph Co. MI. and is buried there. Melinda Roblee's husband is: William Burke Utter b) 1796 his parents are: Joseph Utter Sr. b) 1775 & Dowty ? Utter is the 1st cousin of Polina's husband, William Case. Also it is noted that Polina's b/d is the same as Melinda's-so they are twins, This is all the info I could come up with. For further details your contact is: zacathan@comcast.net per: " Descendents of Phillip Case" To Cindy Waldron: this to is your direct line, within these volumes are mentioned your parents- you are linked to Polina & Melinda directly through your Waldron's, by way of the Case's & Utter's. Hope to hear from you soon. Theresa. --------------------------------- No need to miss a message. Get email on-the-go with Yahoo! Mail for Mobile. Get started. For questions about this list, contact the list administrator at ROBLEE-admin@rootsweb.com. ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to ROBLEE-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message