Hello, All, I must add something to this discussion. I have: Phebe Ann Robblee, 8 May 1813- 23 Jul 1900, d Flint, MI. bur Avondale Cem. Flint. married 21 Jul 1852 at Burke, Franklin, NY. Simeon Montague, 9 Oct 1803- aft 1886, his second wife. Their son, Simeon Calvin Montague, 11 Sept 1853 - 20 May 1865, buried in Burke, buried beside Samuel and Marion Robblee. Their dau. Cora Minerva, 4 Nov 1854, b at Burke. I have come across one record that mentions Phebe Ann was first married to Alvin Crippen? Her brother, Nathan, was also at Flint. Mary "Polly" Robblee, 14 Jul 1811 - 26 Aug 1879 at Victory, NY married 25 Jul 1838 at Ft. Ann, Wa. Co. NY. Benjamin Jakway, 11 Sep 1807 - 11 Aug 1879 at Victory, NY. Source, Genealogy.com. The 1820 Cenus records Nathaniel and John Roblyer at Ulysses, Thomkins, NY. I have not found any Nathaniels in the Roblyer lineage. Do we know the exact dates of the various censuses? People might have been missed around these times. I think the above Phebe and Polly were the daughters of Phillip and Eunice Robblee. The 1820 Census record for Nathanael Robblee is interesting. Would the second male over 45 possibly be his brother, Luther? And were the 2 males under 10, Julius Scott and William Orson? Did not their father, William? pass on in 1820? Was the oldest girl, Phebe? All interesting tidbits of stray info. If anyone has anything further, please let me know and HOpe to hear from you soon. Bob

I found yesterday the 1860 Federal Census for Burke, Franklin County, NY. Simeon Montague; age 57 farmer from MA. Phebe A. Montague: age 47 Simon Montague: age 7 Cora Montague: age 6 Samuel Robe: age 85 born MA This Phebe, the apparent daughter of this Samuel, alive in 1860 is not the Phebe Robblee-Richards that I am looking for borrn 1802. Jim Fortier: you can remove the marriage of this Phebe to John Richards Jr. from your data base. My Phebe died in 1847. Did you ever find out about the other Phebe in Granville? One died young? Cindy said some time ago that we should look closer at Phillip and Eunice's children. Maybe they are the ones. Thanks for the information. Regards, JIM Richards -----Original Message----- From: rrobblee@primus.ca To: Roblee-L@rootsweb.com Sent: Tue, 30 Jan 2007 3:52 PM Subject: [ROBLEE] Phebe? Hello, All, I must add something to this discussion. I have: Phebe Ann Robblee, 8 May 1813- 23 Jul 1900, d Flint, MI. bur Avondale Cem. Flint. married 21 Jul 1852 at Burke, Franklin, NY. Simeon Montague, 9 Oct 1803- aft 1886, his second wife. Their son, Simeon Calvin Montague, 11 Sept 1853 - 20 May 1865, buried in Burke, buried beside Samuel and Marion Robblee. Their dau. Cora Minerva, 4 Nov 1854, b at Burke. I have come across one record that mentions Phebe Ann was first married to Alvin Crippen? Her brother, Nathan, was also at Flint. Mary "Polly" Robblee, 14 Jul 1811 - 26 Aug 1879 at Victory, NY married 25 Jul 1838 at Ft. Ann, Wa. Co. NY. Benjamin Jakway, 11 Sep 1807 - 11 Aug 1879 at Victory, NY. Source, Genealogy.com. The 1820 Cenus records Nathaniel and John Roblyer at Ulysses, Thomkins, NY. I have not found any Nathaniels in the Roblyer lineage. Do we know the exact dates of the various censuses? People might have been missed around these times. I think the above Phebe and Polly were the daughters of Phillip and Eunice Robblee. The 1820 Census record for Nathanael Robblee is interesting. Would the second male over 45 possibly be his brother, Luther? And were the 2 males under 10, Julius Scott and William Orson? Did not their father, William? pass on in 1820? Was the oldest girl, Phebe? All interesting tidbits of stray info. If anyone has anything further, please let me know and HOpe to hear from you soon. Bob For questions about this list, contact the list administrator at ROBLEE-admin@rootsweb.com. ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to ROBLEE-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message ________________________________________________________________________ Check out the new AOL. Most comprehensive set of free safety and security tools, free access to millions of high-quality videos from across the web, free AOL Mail and more.

I missed this when I posted last weekend. Thanks for the detail on Phebe Ann. She is almost certainly the daughter of the Samuel and Marion Roblee you mention as being buried beside her son. I cannot find any sign of an Alvin Crippen in earlier censes, or on the internet. I agree that Mary may be the daughter of Philip and Eunice, although the details are not a perfect fit with census records for Philip. Cindy -----Original Message----- From: roblee-bounces@rootsweb.com [mailto:roblee-bounces@rootsweb.com]On Behalf Of Bob Robblee Sent: Tuesday, January 30, 2007 3:53 PM To: Roblee-L@rootsweb.com Subject: [ROBLEE] Phebe? Hello, All, I must add something to this discussion. I have: Phebe Ann Robblee, 8 May 1813- 23 Jul 1900, d Flint, MI. bur Avondale Cem. Flint. married 21 Jul 1852 at Burke, Franklin, NY. Simeon Montague, 9 Oct 1803- aft 1886, his second wife. Their son, Simeon Calvin Montague, 11 Sept 1853 - 20 May 1865, buried in Burke, buried beside Samuel and Marion Robblee. Their dau. Cora Minerva, 4 Nov 1854, b at Burke. I have come across one record that mentions Phebe Ann was first married to Alvin Crippen? Her brother, Nathan, was also at Flint. Mary "Polly" Robblee, 14 Jul 1811 - 26 Aug 1879 at Victory, NY married 25 Jul 1838 at Ft. Ann, Wa. Co. NY. Benjamin Jakway, 11 Sep 1807 - 11 Aug 1879 at Victory, NY. Source, Genealogy.com. The 1820 Cenus records Nathaniel and John Roblyer at Ulysses, Thomkins, NY. I have not found any Nathaniels in the Roblyer lineage. Do we know the exact dates of the various censuses? People might have been missed around these times. I think the above Phebe and Polly were the daughters of Phillip and Eunice Robblee. The 1820 Census record for Nathanael Robblee is interesting. Would the second male over 45 possibly be his brother, Luther? And were the 2 males under 10, Julius Scott and William Orson? Did not their father, William? pass on in 1820? Was the oldest girl, Phebe? All interesting tidbits of stray info. If anyone has anything further, please let me know and HOpe to hear from you soon. Bob For questions about this list, contact the list administrator at ROBLEE-admin@rootsweb.com. ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to ROBLEE-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message