>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >Subject: VT Vital Records >Date: Fri, 1 May 1998 12:50:38 -0400 >... >Quite a number of years ago, I transcribed all of the Vermont Vital >Records housed in Middlesex, VT) on Rublee. I wasn't absolutely possible >I had checked Robblee and Roblee, so went over today at lunch time to >check. Here is ALL I found: > >Richard Robley m. Lucinda Brewster 20 Apr 1837 Weybridge, VT. His res: > Green Co, IL > >Roblee, Susan L. Burroughs d. 2 Aug 1905 Rutland, VT at 63,11,--. She >was b. Cambridgeport, MA, dau. of Henry Burroughs and Susan Whitcomb. > >I guess not many of those Granville folks snuck over the border to be >born, marry or die. > >Cindy

>Date: Sun, 3 May 1998 23:42:26 -0400 (EDT) >From: Phil Roblee <[email protected]> >... >I sit here (in the background) observing historic geneological references >flashing across my screen like fireflies on a summer night, and I think, >"Wow! These folks have done their homework!" To those of you who have >been in the trenches digging, questioning, challenging, and digging some >more...I thank you. On behalf of those (of us) who have benefitted from >your hard work without ourselves putting much time in the field, I say, >"thank you" again for allowing us to grab your coat-tails. >... >I hope the "Thomas" issue will be at a concensus stage soon, resolved by >various and upcoming trips to parts of Washington D.C., Vermont and >Massachusetts. > >I am confident of claiming my rightful place in the Roblee (Robblee et >al) line by proving a direct link between gggrandfather Orlando Roblee, >his father Calvin Roblee, and the "Thomas" group. Just a small reminder >to those of you fortunate in your access to source documents to keep your >eyes peeled for references to Orlando Roblee (b: Oct 1829), son of >Calvin. (Many of you are familiar with this query...others new to the e->mail web may not be)....

>Date: Sun, 26 Apr 1998 11:59:40 -0400 >From: [email protected] (Carol Thomas) >Subject: 1850-1860 Johnsburg census/Roblee >... >Hope I'm posting this correctly to reach the list. I will add to this as >time allows. > >Roblee families >1850 Census Town of Johnsburg, Warren Co., NY > >No. 129- William ag 29; Susan A. ag 25; Electa J. ag 7 > >No. 130- Calvin ag 63; Francis (assume it should be Frances, CT) ag 66 > >No. 191- Lyman ag 20; Anne ag 18; Calvin ag 2 > >No. 194- Theron ag 60; Ann ag 60; Sidney J. ag 27; Olive J. (Downs, CT) ag >25; Milo R. ag 4; Selina A. ag 3; Wallace M. no age; George Sanders ag 15 > >No. 195- Theron ag 38; Maria ag 34; Thomas S. ag 9; Hiram C. ag 7; Lyman M. >ag 5; William ag 2; Washington no age > >No. 196- George ag 36; Sally ag 31; John T. ag 8; Theron J. ag 4 > >No. 200- Luther ag 65; Oxy ag 62; Isaac ag 20; Sally ag.17 > >No. 242- Norman ag 34; Adeline ag 33; Amelia ag 13; Charles ag 11; >Francelia ag 9; Edwin ag 7; James ag 4 > >1855 Census Town of Johnsburg, Warren Co., NY > >No. 5- William ag 34, b Wash. Co., 28 yrs J'burg, Frame house; Susan ag 30, >Electa Jane ag 12, William Harrison ag 2 all b Warren Co.; Moses ag 20 b >VT, laborer, 1 yr J'burg; Calvin ag 68, b Wash Co, 28 yrs J'burg, father; >Fanny ag 71, b Wash. Co, mother > >No. 63- Norman ag 40, b Wash. Co., 7 yrs J'burg, Frame House; Adelia ag 38, >b Rens. Co., 7 yrs J'burg; Amelia ag 18, William C. ag 16, Francelia ag 14, >Edwin ag 12, James B. ag 9 all born Orleans Co., NY; Theodore ag 4, b >Warren Co., NY. Also George Saunders ag 20 b Wash. Co., 9 yrs J'burg; >Alfred Wyman ag 22 b Genessee Co., 2 yrs J'burg; Mary Carey ag 17, b Warren >Co., servant; Elias Mosier ag 50, b VT > >No 68- Luther ag 70, b Wash. Co., 11 yrs J'burg, Frame house; Roxey ag 67, >b Wash. Co. > >No. 70- Isaac ag 24, b Wash. Co., 11 yrs J'burg, no occupation listed; >Sally Ann ag 23, b Warren Co.; Betsy L. ag 4, Abigail ag 2, Harriet no age >given all born Warren Co., NY > >No. 71- Theron ag 66, b Wash. Co., 24 yrs J'burg, Frame house; Ann ag 65 b >Wash. Co.; Russell Fuller ag 42 b Warren Co.; Sophia Goodman ag 65, b MA; >Harriett Stores ag 27, b Warren Co.; Darwin Wicke ag 29, b VT > >No. 72- Theron Jr. ag 43, b Wash. Co., 28 yrs J'burg, Frame house; Nancy ag >37, b Warren Co.; Thomas ag 14, Hiram ag 11, Lyman ag 8, William A. ag 5, >Washington ag 3, Malden ag 2, all born Warren Co., NY > >No. 84- George ag 40, b Wash. Co., 28 yrs J'burg, Board house; Sally ag >35, John T. ag 13, Theron ag 9, George W. ag 2 all born Warren Co., NY > >No. 88- Lyman M. ag 32, b Wash. Co., 28 yrs J'burg, Frame house; Emma E. ag >25, 8 yrs J'burg; Calvin O. ag 7, Chauncey Smith ag 22, Martha Smith ag 22, >Sidney Smith ag 18, all born Warren Co., NY; Smith family listed as >boarders > >No. 123- Elisha ag 21, b Warren Co., Board house; Jane M. ag 21, Hamilton >R. ag 2, both born Warren Co., NY > >No. 136- Luther ag 42, b Wash. Co., 15 yrs J'burg, Frame house; Margaret ag >41, b Rens. Co., 15 yrs J'burg; Charles ag 14, Hugh ag 9, both born Warren >Co.; John White ag 42, b VT; Daniel Forbes ag 40, b ME > >1860 Census Town of Johnsburg > >No. 59- William ag 38, hotelkeeper, b NY; Susan ag 36, Electa J. ag 17, >William H. ag 7, all born NY; George Little ag 23, Doctor, b NY; Thomas >Eldridge ag 40, b NY; Jacob Miller ag 20, b Canada; Frank Carroll ag 20, b >Canada; Catherine Bowers ag 19, b Ireland > >No. 134- George ag 46, Farmer, b NY; Sally ag 41, John ag 18, Theron ag >14, George D. ag 7, Samuel ag 2, David N. no age given, all born NY > >No. 136- Lyman ag 37, Hotelkeeper, b NY; Emma ag 30, Land lady, b NY; >Calvin O. ag 11, Henry C. ag 6, Calvin ag 73, Farm laborer, all born NY; >Jane Ingalls ag 20, Servant, b NY; Norman Ovitt ag 23, Laborer, b NY; >Washington Stiles ag 20, Laborer, b NY; Samuel Rist ag 35, Carpenter, b NY; >David Ovitt ag 37, Laborer, b NY > >No. 186- Norman ag 45, Farmer, b NY; Adelia ag 44, Charles ag 22, Francelia >ag 18, Edwin ag 16, James ag 14, Theodore ag 9, all b NY; Delinda Russell >ag 20, Servant, b NY; John Maynard ag 12, b NY > >No. 187- Theron Jr. ag 48, Farmer, b NY; Nancy ag 44, Thomas ag 19, Hiram >ag 17, Lyman ag 15, William ag 12, Washington ag 10, Malden ag 7, Ann ag 4, >Martha ag 2, all born NY > >No. 188- Theron ag 71, b NY; Ann ag 70, b NY > >No. 189- Isaac ag 30, Farmer, b NY; Sally ag 27, Betsy ag 10, Abigail ag 8, >Chloe ag 4, Henry ag 1, Luther ag 75, Farmer, all born NY > >No. 190- Luther ag 47, b NY; Margaret ag 46, Charles ag 18, Hugh ag 15, >Sophia Waldron ag 12, all born NY > >No. 191- Elisha ag 29, Farm laborer, b NY; Mary ag 26, Hamilton ag 7, >Adaline ag 1, all born NY >

>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >To: "'[email protected]'" <[email protected]> >Date: Sun, 3 May 1998 19:33:38 -0400 > >...I also hope to get to the >Library of Congress to take a look at Armida Sharpin's lengthy Rapalje >genealogy called Rapelje Rasters. Still looking to prove or disprove >that connection, as I keep stumbling across it. The Raplee material in >the History of Yates Co., NY states that they believe they are Rapalje >descendants. Also, an article in a Canadian publication called Huguenot >Trails (Spring 1978) summarizes information submitted by Mrs. Margot Hall >of New Brunswick. She states that she is a desc. of John Rapalje, who >immigrated to Bear River , NS. The article says that the family >homestead is known as the Robblee homestead. She has in her possession a >portrait entitled The Rapalje Children, painted circa 1768. > >When you are a number of years into your research, time devoted to >research tends to yield less and less -- and sometimes nothing at all. >Frustrating at times -- but this e-mail list has at least regenerated my >enthusiam for my research on this family...

>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >Subject: RE: Two References. >Date: Sun, 3 May 1998 16:32:53 -0400 > >My atlas, which is a pretty detailed one, shows towns called Rutland in BC, FL, IL, MA, ND and VT. None of those is very close to PA. > >Cindy

>Date: Sun, 03 May 1998 12:51:04 -0700 >From: [email protected] >Subject: Two References. > >Hi, Ro[u]b[b]lee Cousins; > I got a note from Jim Fortier today and he queries my source for the >Thomas Roblee, 1781-1812, which is the burial record taken from Aaron >Goodspeed's [of Granville, NY. 1862-1932] notebooks edited by Allen D. >Hill from the Bennington Museum, Inc. Old Bennington, VT. I believe this >man, whose gravesite is in the North Hartford, NY burying ground and who >is recorded as Junior, is a son of Thomas Rubbelee whose family is >recorded in the 1790 Census at Granville, NY. > As you all know, our family name prior to 1850, seems to take on the >common spelling used in the particular area that they happened to living >at the time. Today, I was going over some notes I received from Nolah >Bolli of Burwell, NE. She traces her ancestry to Andrew Jackson Roblyer, >born 1808, NY. lived 1850, Tioga Co. PA. She quotes from a book, A >History of Tioga Co. published 1883. In it are mentioned 2 Roblyer women >who had married Northrop Smith, born Ridgefield, Conn. 1819, Farmer. The >first was Hannah Roblyer, of Rutland, who died 1841 leaving 2 children. >The other was Sally A. Roblyer, also of Rutland. Is there a Rutland in >PA? or might this refer to VT? My atlas doesn't note one in PA. > Hope to hear from you soon. >Bob Robblee >

>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >Subject: re: Lynda Mc's message about Vermont records etc. >Date: Sun, 3 May 1998 13:14:19 -0400 > >In response to Lynda McGinnis's message: > >Actually, I have found Vermont records surprisingly easy to >access. The vital records are all centralized at Public Records >in Middlesex. Sometime in the middle 1850's, Vermont passed a >vital records law. It required all town clerks to send in, on >cards, their information on births, deaths and marriages. To the >extent that these vital records are recorded in the towns, they are >quite well consolidated in Middlesex. I have heard that it is not >perfect -- that sometimes the towns have records that the state >does not. Also, of course, not all births, deaths and marriage got >recorded. I have transcribed all of the Rublee names from 1760 to >at least 1954, and that information is reflected in my database. >I am pretty sure -- but not absolutely sure -- that I transcribed >any name variations I found, but I need to go back and make check. >I did this very early on in my research, and I am not sure that, >at that time, I was clued into the variety of names we all know now >to be related. As I have had time, I have also looked up birth >records for all of the Rublee spouses, and children for the first >generation of Rublee daughters. > >Not only are the vital records consolidated in Middlesex, but that >office also has microfilmed versions of early Vermont town records. >This includes the land records. Next, public records has >microfilms of all of the probate court indices. They have >microfilms of the actual probate records - wills and estate records >- to about 1850. This is where I transcribed some of the early >Rublee wills. The later ones are in the individual courts. > >Middlesex is actually the next town over from where I work. >Unfortunately, they are open the same hours I work. > >The Vermont census records are also available both in Montpelier >and in Burlington. All in all, records are pretty consolidated. > >Lynda -- I have heard that the Bennington Museum has a nice >genealogical collection. If you are planning a trip to Bennington >Co. this summer, you might want to check it out. I have that on >my list of things to do, along with a trip to Albany. > >Cindy Walcott > > >e-mail: [email protected] >

>Date: Sat, 02 May 1998 18:39:46 -0700 >From: [email protected] (James Fortier) >Subject: Gedcom > >Bob [ROBBLEE]: >Thanks for the GEDCOM file. I found it very interesting. Your point >about it being unlikely that Reuben Robblee b. 1738 would be a tenant in >the Town of Souteast in 1754 was well taken. I have trouble with >Thinking that Reuben is the son of a Thomas Robblee. I have seen no >evidence of a Thomas Robblee who could be the father of Reuben. If >Reuben m. Phoebe Austin was the Reuben born in 1738 in Huntington, LI, >then I think he could only be the son of William or Andrew. These are >the only two Robblees who show up in the Records of Huntington from this >time period. If there were a Thomas, I would expect to see a sign of >him. Thomas first shows up in Nine Partners/Crum Elbow Precinct >(Dutchess co.) in 1766. >As far as the children of Andrew and William. I think the Huntginton >baptisms can be fit into 2 families. This is purely conjectural. >William M. 1727 Abigail Brush >Ch. William Jr. b. 1733 >Thomas b. 1735 >Reuben b. 1738 >John b. 1740 > >Andrew m. 1733 Abigail Hawkins >Ch. Hannah b. 1734 >Andrew b. 1736 > >I am interested in your source for Thomas Robblee b. 1781 d. 1812 > >Jim Fortier >

>Date: Thu, 30 Apr 1998 19:56:18 -0400 >From: [email protected] (Carol Thomas) >Subject: Re: Misc. Roblee women > >>Here are a couple of Roblee women - Abigail . b. cir 1812 , and Chloe, >>b. cir 1792 - I found on the internet. I don't have them in my >>database. >> Both married men by the name of Waite, who were born in >>Petersburgh,Rensselaer,NY . > >Cindy, > >In Luther Robblee's will listed among the heirs was Chloe Wait, West >Berlin, St. Clair, MI. Did you know that Waite/Wait/Waist is often become >West? > > >Will dated 19 Jan 1860. Left to Isaac H. and/or his children, homestead >farm and 84 acres and 33 acres of land sold to Luther by Robert Gilchrist >and others, totalling 200 acres. >To daughter, Mary Whitcomb, wife of Flynn, her portion of the 200 acres (33 >acres). >To son, Luther portion of 200 acres (33 acres). >Remainder of acreage to be sold to pay debts. (Apparently wasn't enough, >see below.) >To Roxy Delilah Roblee, best goose feather bed and bedstead with bedding. >Calvin Washburn appointed executor, but he renounced appointment. Flynn >Whitcomb appointed in his place. >Luther signed his own name to will: LUTHER ROBBLEE. >Survivors named in will: Luther, Mary, Betsey, Chloe, Eliza, Isaac, >Orlando, Melvina, Charles and Roxy. No wife mentioned. >In 1861: >Chloe Wait, West Berlin, St. Clair, MI >Mary Whitcomb, Granville, NY >Melvina Cornell >Roxy of Warsaw, Wyoming Co., NY >Eliza Cottrell, Troy, NY >Ira A. Paddock appointed special guardian for Roxy, 14 >File includes notice of death; notice of public sale of homestead farm and >acreage to pay debts. >

>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >To: "'[email protected]'" <[email protected]> >Subject: Misc. Roblee women >Date: Thu, 30 Apr 1998 08:25:31 -0400 >... >Here are a couple of Roblee women - Abigail . b. cir 1812 , and Chloe, b. >cir 1792 - I found on the internet. I don't have them in my database. > Both married men by the name of Waite, who were born in >Petersburgh,Rensselaer,NY .

>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >Subject: Western Canadian Rublees >Date: Wed, 29 Apr 1998 07:26:21 -0400 >...This message was actually written last week, but had a >delivery problem. It was in response to a message posted by Bob Robblee. > [Cindy Walcott] I'll try again. > > >The Western Canadian Rublees (including Merritt -- actually there are two >Merritts that I know of. One died in AB in 1997, and another was in SK >in the 70's.) are related to me. Our mutual ancestor is Andrew Rublee, >son of William Robblee of Lanesborough, MA. They went from northern VT >to QC and on out to AB and SK, Canada. I am in touch with some of them. > >Cindy >

>Date: Wed, 29 Apr 1998 09:00:33 -0400 >From: [email protected] (Lynda McGinnis) >Subject: DAR Records >... >Hi cousins, > The best way to find out what proof exsists at the DAR is to either >visit the library in person or, a member can write and request a >photocopy of any documents of proof contained in the veteran's file. >Unfortunately, the older the DAR application is, the less likely that >there was ever any real proof submitted to substantiate the lineage. > > Fortunately, the DAR has stopped this careless practice of believing >what ever people claimed as their ancestral lines. For the past several >years they have required that every application be accompanied with >mountains of proof for every date, location, name, link, etc.. >Unfortunately, for the Thomas Robblee >line, there is not likely going to be anything in the file. I will write >to see >if there is and will let you know. As for William Robblee, the most >recently >submitted lineage on him is probably my own :-) Everything that I >submitted has >been sent to Cindy for the database. >Lynda

>Date: Tue, 28 Apr 1998 21:20:15 -0700 >From: [email protected] >... >I just had another look at the mortgage given to David Doane by a >Samuel Robblee and his mother Phebe, dated 16 Jun 1805. It reserves an >acre to Samuel Stanley conveyed to him by Thomas Robblee in 1802. The >way I would read this information is that Thomas owned the land and was >able to transfer it to Samuel Stanley. After 1802 and before 1805, >Thomas died, possibly late 1804, early 1805. As part of the proceedings, >I would suggest the land had to be sold. And this was being done by >Samuel Robblee and his mother Phebe. Is there possibly a will filed >where this mortgage is located at the county clerk's office at 383 >Broadway, Ft. Edward, NY. 12838? If not a will, a copy of surrogate >proceedings for a person dying intestate? Thomas' will,[married Chloe >Evarts] makes specific reference to this very thing. > >...I finally tracked down that gravesite iformation you [Lynda McGinnis] >wanted. Thomas Roblee Jr. died 25 Jan 1812 is buried in the North >Hartford Burying >Ground, NY. listed on Page 6 of the Compilation of Aaron Goodspeed's >field books by Allen D. Hill, Bennington Museum, INC. Old Bennington, >Vt. >Also burid there and listed next to Thomas is Mrs Sophia Baker [born >Middlebury, VT.] died at 76 years on 29 Jan 1890. Buried with her is >Martha J. oldest daughter of T. and S. Roblee Baker, Age 10 yrs. 9 mos. >died 29 Sep 1849. The other thing I find interesting about this >graveyard is that there are other names that tie into the family as >well. Case and Northup to mention two. Hope you can find out more on >your travels this summer to the Bennington Area. I can appreciate your >comments on the fact that every little area has jealously maintained its >own records and it becomes necessary to visit every one. Here most of >our records are domiciled at the Provincial [State] archives which can >cut down the number of locales to search. > >Dear Phil [Roblee], > I still believe we will find your Calvin's family east of Granville >in Vt. > >Dear Cindy [Walcott], > I see as I look at the DAR records that I have that they tend to >piggyback onto a previous record and then use it as proof. I guess that >I would hope that we may come across on with a different point of view. >If nothing else, if may lead to another branch of the tree. >...

>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >>Subject: RE: 1850/55/60 Census >Date: Tue, 28 Apr 1998 06:40:57 -0400 > >I noticed this Moses too, and wondered about him. If he really is a Roblee, he's a new one to me too. > > >Cindy >

>Date: Sun, 26 Apr 1998 22:38:24 -0700 >From: [email protected] >Subject: Thomas Rubbelee > >Dear Lynda [McGinnis], > I will send you a copy of Milo's original notes as soon as I get >some more copies made. > On the subject of Thomas, I believe that there is a record of his >service in the record of MA. where 4 men, William, Reuben, Thomas and >Thomas Robble are mentioned. One Thomas married Chloe Evarts and the >other is our mystery man. His family is also, I believe, recorded in the >Census of 1790 in Granville, NY and the family structure is similiar to >Reuben's. It lists 2 males over 16, which rules out this record as being >that of Thomas married Chloe, unless he had started having kids about >the age of 15. Not much else has been found, but there is a gravesite >record I have seen for a Thomas Roblee, Jr. died 1812, from the Aaron >Goodspeed fieldbooks that are held at the Bennington museum. Ralph >Roblee of San Diego sent me part of that record, but I need to see the >rest so as to clarify it better. > Hope to hear from you soon. >Bob Robblee >

>Date: Sun, 26 Apr 1998 22:03:38 -0700 >From: [email protected] >Subject: 1850/55/60 Census >... >Dear Carol [THOMAS], > I just finished going through the records you sent. Most of it >seems to match my files, but I will go through them once more in the AM >when things are often clearer. > I noticed one thing in the 1855 Census for Johnsburg that seems to >be a loose end.In the listing for William Roblee, married Susan, dau. >Electa, son Wm. Harrison, there is a record for a Moses, ag 20, born VT. >Is this a listing for Roblee? and would you let us know? > Hope to hear from you soon. >Bob Robblee >

>From: Cindy Walcott <[email protected]> >Subject: RE: Milo's notes >Date: Mon, 27 Apr 1998 19:04:23 -0400 >... >Hello all -- > >re: DAR > >I have looked at some DAR records, but have not found much help. The old >DAR records are pretty undocumented. I will try to pull what I have. I >usually travel to DC a couple of times a year on business, so get to the >DAR then, if I can. They have a phenomenal library. I have used to try to >fill in Rublee/Robblee/Roblee information from the female side, but the >families are remarkably elusive. I have had some success, but limited. > >re: Census etc, > >Carol [THOMAS] -- I take it the 1855 census was the NY state census? >That one was >particularly helpful, as I don't have access to the state censes for NY. > >There is a recent book on Granville cemeteries by Margaret Jenks, which I >have access to. I have copied all of the relevent entries. Also, has >anyone seen Laura Huslander's catalog on Washington Co. books? Quite an >extensive listing. I assume most of the books are available locally. I >have seen some. Also, Laura did a search for me in the indices of the >books she carries. Not much turned up. > >Cindy >

>Date: Mon, 27 Apr 1998 13:19:40 -0400 >From: [email protected] (Lynda McGinnis) >Subject: Thomas Robblee, Soldier of VT >... >Hi Everyone, > I"m curious about the Thomas Robblee of southern VT and who supposedly >served in the Revolution and etc. Does anyone have thoughts on who he was? Any >proof of his children? I've written to several towns in VT and they had no >records at all of any Robblee's having been there. Did he really live there or >is he one of the Granville Robblees or??? >Lynda >

>Date: Sun, 26 Apr 1998 07:58:48 -0700 >From: [email protected] >Subject: Milo's notes >... >Dear Mark [ROBLEE], > I will get the notes in the mail. I have come across Lenore's DAR >record in my files and will send that along as well. Other DAR numbers >that could help us are listed in the 3 that I have on file are: 476122, >244356, 398577, 239285, 221727, 26971, 433895, 329087, 235032, and >355611. Does anyone have access to the DAR files to get these pulled? >The 3 I have are 26971, 239285, and 476122. > >Dear Carol [THOMAS], > Thanks for the Census record. Some answers, more questions. Great. >I wonder if we can find the book, Early Gravestone Records of Granville, >Wa. Co. NY and nearby Cemetaries in Wa. Co. and Vt. This was compiled by >Allen D. Hill based on the field books prepared by Aaron Goodspeed of >Granville, NY. [1862-1932]. Hopefully, it covers a lot of the >surrounding area. >Dear Doug, > I have made the correction in your family line. I'll add the rest >after I learn how to download from the netsite. In the notes I got from >you last spring, it is mentioned that Norman Roblee was brought up by >his brother Thomas, married Chloe Evarts. I believe that that should be >Thomas, married Laura Robblee. If Thomas, married Chloe Evarts, was the >brother, then Norman would have been born the year his mother, Phoebe >Austin, died. Notes are to that effect in Carpenter from Marion Roblee >Barnard, great grandaughter of Norman. I will also send along notes that >were acquired from Helen Roblee Barnard of Granville that I got from >Joyce Atkin. ... Doug Detling's added comment: Bob is correct here. The error is introduced in one of the extracted listings from the so-called "Carpenter Manuscript, see later messages for this. Norman Roblee was brought up by his older brother, Thomas (who married his cousin Laura Robblee) after the death of Thomas' and Norman's parents.

>Date: 27 Apr 98 09:21:21 +0000 >From: Mark Roblee <[email protected]> >Subject: RE: Various Genealogies >... >Dear Bob [ROBBLEE], > >It will likely take a few weeks before I can get Lenore's research from >my father. Sorry for the delay! And, yes, I'd love to see Milo's >notes....how do the Carpenter's fit in again? > >Mark