I think I answered the question myself... by birth, correct? In the 1880 Federal Census of Pike, Wyoming Co, NY I found the following family: John Robinson, age 50, white, head of household, farm laborer, born NY, both parents born NY, Unice Robinson, age 44, white, wife, keeping house, born NY, both parents born NY Willard Robinson, age 22, white, son, single, born NY Hiram Robinson, age 14, white, son, single, born NY Ella Robinson, age 13, white, daughter, single, born NY Mary Robinson, age 11, white, daughter, single, born NY Myra Robinson, age 9, white, daughter, single, born NY John Robinson, age 7, white, son, single, born NY Henry Robinson, age 5, white, son, single, born NY Fred Robinson, age 2, white, son, single, born NY There is no 1890 Census available. What was her husband's name? Perhaps I can track her through 1930. I did find a family tree on Ancestry.com that included a Myra Ida Robinson, born in 1871, but it's a private tree that can't be viewed. Wendy