Hi Donna - I have four Dorcas Gardiners, plus a Dorkus Gardner, but none of them are a child of Nicholas. The term brother may refer to a brother-in-law. Is it possible that Dorcas was not the daughter, but the daughter-in-law of Nicholas? Sorry I can't be of more help. - Lauren Lauren Maehrlein Maehrlein's Heirlines Plant a tree, then start your family tree!