Hi Folks I been dragging a stick in the mud, setting under my shed here trying to stay dry. My mind has pondered a lot. You know, proof is sometimes hard to come by. I don't have much proof, so when proof is not available I was taught (by a very steer old Colonel) you must use logic. So I don't have proof, but what if? Father 1. 1775 0 75 Kit #24403 2. Are they brothers and sons of #1 1796 21 52 Kit #23661 1806 31 48 Kit #28391 3. Are they brothers or sons of which one, 1796 or 1806. 1823 48 31 Kit #24404 1827 52 21 Kit #29459 4. Son of 1823 or 1827. 1850 75 0 Kit #25626 Joseph's (kit #29459) first child was born 27 Nov. 1856, and was a girl. The question is what son belongs to who. Anyone have the answers? From the Home of Jimmy and JoAnne Redmond Sr