You don't give a year of birth on Lillie. The only Ohio birth indices I found in a quick scan of Ancestry.com were for Toledo, Ohio for 1888-1895. Did not run a search there as it may not be your time frame. I don't know where you got the "born in Ohio" info, but remember that if it's from a census record, it could be wrong. Many of my family members show up with different birthplaces from census to census, and even places of birth on death certificates can be wrong if the informant gets confused, is misinformed, or just guesses. I try to get as many secondary records as I can and then compare them, and usually consider the earliest record I find to be the most accurate as there is less time for memories to get fuzzy. On 12/7/08, Kathryn McKee <[email protected]> wrote: > > > I also found my grandmother Sadie Weiss as a servant in NYC, and learned > that her eldest daughter, Lillie, was born in Ohio. The problem I have with > Lillie is I don't know her last name as she allegedly had a different father > whose name I don't know.