Hi Karen Checked out this certificate for your William Petrie and as we suspected found he had also married Helen Bell..... Marriage Certificate Ref: 1869 St. Andrew, DUNDEE (282-4) Page 92 Entry 184 (source Scottish Records Office) On 09 August 1869 at 17 Janefield Place, Dundee (after banns of Free Church of Scotland) WILLIAM PETRIE Yarn Warper Widower of ANN BELL age 31 of 15 Arbroath Road, Forfar Parents: THOMAS PETRIE - Baker Journeyman MARJORY PETRIE ms MILL HELEN BELL (her x mark) Widow of WILLIAM ALLARDICE age 26 of 4 Nursery Feus, Forfar Parents: GEORGE BELL - Linen Weaver HELEN BROWN Witnesses: JAMES WILSON JAMES McINTOSH ********** Note Mother : Marjory Mill aka Marjory Milne Cheerio Norma