Kaye, I decided to start over, Babe- on a hunch i viewed Caroline's birth and it is Isabel Shewster Robertson there is a correction in the margin....but her parents are John Robertson, Coachman, and Barbara Bell, whose marriage was thankfully after 1855! October 31 1856 in Perth. born at littleton, culteguhey? very hard to read Fowlis wester. I felt like I wasn't helping and now I found her birth....so next I'm trying her death. I printed it off and you can either get on and do it or I can mail it to you if you like. I am going after the marriage now that my search engine is going! your friend, MARY in Oregon