David Cable Mackie died St Andrews 1928. An obituary named pallbearers, of which William Walker (brother-in-law) was one. This sole reference via LDS index of marriages found Descendants of Elizabeth Matthews McDonald 1 Elizabeth Matthews McDonald b: 21 August 1864 in Dundee, Angus, Scotland d: Aft. 1950 . married William Walker m: 1895 in Dundee, Angus 1901 census found children . 2 Anna Elizabeth Walker b: 1896 Dundee, Angus . 2 Margaret Evelyn Walker b: 1901 Dundee, Angus recently IGI found birth 1 Daniel Walker . +Anna Eliza Keith . 2 William Walker b: 28 December 1855 in Dundee, Angus, Scotland but a search for the marriage of Daniel & Anna found nothing while a parent search found only William. So to scotlandspeople for the marriage certificate of William & Elizabeth which produced District of St Peter in the Burgh of Dundee Marriage 12 June 1895 at 73 Annfield Road, Dundee William Walker, bank teller 40 parents Daniel Walker, Inspestor of Factories, Anna Eliza Walker m/s Neish Elizabeth M McDonald, 30 parents John McDonald grocer Agnes Grieve McDonald m/s Fyfe SO Williams mother was Anna Eliza Neish, NOT Anna Eliza Keith. The IGI was incorrect. Search for the marriage and children now found 1 Daniel Walker . +Anna Eliza Neish m: 21 July 1847 in St Peter, Dundee, Angus . 2 Anna Isabella Walker b: 06 March 1849 in Dundee, Angus, . 2 Jane Walker b: 18 March 1851 in Dundee, Angus . 2 Georgina Webster Walker b: 27 November 1852 in Dundee, Angus, . 2 Margaret Neish Walker b: 21 August 1854 in Dundee, Angus, . 2 Richard Walkerb: 22 February 1858 in Dundee, Angus . 2 Mary Walker b: 01 September 1859 in Dundee, Angus And to confirm William search via scotlandspeople for the birth of William Walker in 1855 BUT nothing located!!(Error no 2). Then a thought, birth was 28 Dec 1855, was it registered in 1856? New search found the certificate, registered 14 Jan 1856, horrid writing. IGI transcription of Neish as Keith explained! Family now found is 1 Thomas Neish . +Anna Mann m: 27 May 1816 in Dundee, Angus . 2 Anna Eliza Neishb: 12 July 1817 in Dundee, Angus, Scotland +Daniel Walker m: 21 July 1847 in St Peter, Dundee, Angus 3 Anna Isabella Walker b: 06 March 1849 in Dundee, Angus, 3 Jane Walker b: 18 March 1851 in Dundee, Angus, 3 Georgina Webster Walker b: 27 November 1852 in Dundee, 3 Margaret Neish Walker b: 21 August 1854 in Dundee, 3 William Walker b: 28 December 1855 in Broughty Ferry +Elizabeth Matthews McDonald b: 21 August 1864 in Dundee, Angus, Scotland m: 12 June 1895 in St Peter, Dundee, Angus d: Aft. 1950 4 Anna Elizabeth Walker b: 25 June 1896 in St Peter, Dundee, Angus 4 Margaret Evelyn Walker b: 13 February 1901 St Peter, Dundee, Angus 3 Richard Walker b: 22 February 1858 in Dundee, Angus, 3 Mary Walker b: 01 September 1859 in Dundee, Angus, Ian Mackie Melbourne