Hello Rhoda. I hadn't seen this previously so thank you. Mike -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hi Mike I have found Caroline in 1851. She and John were living in Seafield Place, Cullen, Banffshire. These are the details (with my brackets): John MACKAY, 34, Head, born Shurton, Caithness [(this is the Ancestry transcription. There is a 'Shurton' in Shetland, but probably should be 'Thurso'] Minister "Face" Church, Cullen [Free? church] Caroline C MACKAY, 22, wife, born Perth, Perthshire Barbara MILNE, 29, servant, born Speymouth, Morayshire Jane MCKENZIE, 14, servant, born Cullen, Banffshire. Rhoda