Al, Have you been able to confirm the info from PP 1 & PP3 that you posted? It seems that many of the dates differ by a couple a years in PP11 which isn't a major concern. But an issue that I'm curious to resolve is the apparent conflict with John b abt 1764 who married Graves and Parker. In PP11, I believe it states that this John was the s/o Elizabeth and Joseph Pennington rather than John George Pennington and Mary Pair (Pare) The same article in PP11 says that David, s/o John George "probably never married". I also show that in PP11, John George's wife is listed as Mary Smith yet in PP17 there is some evidence to support Mary Pare as his wife. I've not seen the PP17v2 article. Could you share what that evidence is, or anything else you know on the subject. I've not worked much in this area to get more concrete sources other than PP, but it's these types of conflicts in the PRA publications I'd like to see work out. I'm still reviewing the rest , but these are some good issues to get resolved if we can. Steve P