Al, A couple more conflicts here.. I find in "Virginia Marriage Index, 1740-1850" by Jordan Dodd et. al., a marriage between Joseph Pennington and Nancy Pennington on 14 Feb., 1811, in Sussex Co. The same book also lists a marriage between Croshor Graves & Rebecca Pennington on 18 Nov., 1826, also in Sussex Co. As this is a secondary source there may be errors in it.... but it makes me question what you show below. And just to document in the archives for future researchers and anyone else following this, you've agreed that John (1764-1823) was the 6th child of Elizabeth & Joseph Pennington rather than being the 6th child of JG Pennington. Steve P Group 10 jmatth98 wrote: <SNIP> > John Pennington, 1764-1823, of Mecklenburg, VA. was the sixth child of > John George Pennington. > John married (1) in 1786 to Sally Graves and had 8 children: > 1. Patcy, 1788- > 2. Thomas, 1790- > 3. Nancy, 1791- > 4. David, 1793-1832 > 5. Henry, 1795-1849, married Lucy Graves Adkins > 6. William Graves, 1798- > 7. Richard, 1800- > 8. Rebecca J. (Pennington), 1802- , married Joseph L. > Pennington. > John married (2) in 1817 to Temperance Parker and has 2 children: > 9. John Joseph Parker Pennington, ca 1819- > 10. Robert Simpson Pennington, Ca 1819- <SNIP>