For all persons connected with Group 2: I submitted a query to Gene at the PRA site regarding Frank & Robert to see if he had any information to help me, but he did not. I wondered if anyone else had any information to add, perhaps even from the 1850 census. In order to connect to group 2 or petition to form another group I need to locate a Robert Pennington, living in Clearfield County, in 1851. My grandfather was Frank (Franklin) Pennington born in Clearfield Co, PA 03/01/1851, son of a Robert Pennington and a Susan Little Pennington (per obit) whom I can locate no other information on other than Frank's obit and a cousin who confirmed they lived in Clearfield at the time of Frank's birth. Also, in regards to the DNA study, my brothers (4 are still living) are direct male descendants from this Frank Pennington. If I can connect to group 2, I can provide DNA for this line. So far, this is an unbroken male line from 1851 to the present. If I can find Robert, it would be an even longer line. Edna Pennington-Gable PRA Member Hiram, GA