Joel - you got it right - according to descendants Nathaniel Pate b. c 1810/1820 (there is debate on this year of birth) md (1) Nancy A Among their children was: Nathaniel C Pate, b. c 1846 md 15 Dec 1872 Mary Etta Treadaway Nathaniel Pate b. c 1810/20 md (2) 25 May 1879 Juliett Weaver-Treadaway Mary Etta Treadaway was a daughter of Juliett Weaver-Treadaway and a step sister to her husband, Nathaniel C Pate. Jinks