These were half sisters to Robert Conaway Pate Daughters of (Robert) Hamilton Pate and 2nd Ux, Nancy Parker Sarah E Pate 18 md William I Waggoner 21 in Clay Co IL 31 Jul 1881 Malinda C Pate 16 md 1st Joseph Mulvaney 24 in Clay Co IL 23 Nov 1882 Malinda C Pate md 2nd James M Dernall 23 in Clay Co IL 31 Aug 1886 Mary Adaline Pate 24 md Thomas Richey 22 in Clay Co IL 5 Oct 1893