Can someone help me with this? in Alice Freeman Thompson Parke lineage they say: In The Genealogist 4 (1983): 184, note #25, Neil D. Thompson calls to our attention an article by Geoffrey W.S. Barrow in The Scottish Genealogist 25 (1978): 98, which disclaims any connection between Maldred, Lord of Carlisle and Allerdale, to the royal house of Scotland. In addition, the Capetian line via, among other families, Wake and Duston, first posited by George Andrews Moriarty, Jr., and dependent on a stained-glass window inscription, is no longer tenable. What line is that? which part is not true now? Descendants of Maldred Lord of Carlisle and and Allendale 1 Maldred Lord of Carlisle and and Allendale ... +Edith of Northumberland .... 2 Gospatrick I Earl of Northumberland of Dunbar .......... 3 Gospatrick II 2nd Earl of Dunbar ................ +Sybil Morel ................ 4 Juliana of Dunbar ...................... +Ralph de Merlay ...................... 5 Roger de Merlay ............................ +Alice de Stuteville ............................ 6 Agnes de Merlay .................................. +Richard Gobion .................................. 7 Hugh Gobion ........................................ +Matilda ........................................ 8 Joan Gobion .............................................. +John de Morteyn ............................................... 9 Sir John de Morteyn ..................................................... +Joan de Rothwell ..................................................... 10 Lucy de Morteyn ........................................................... +Sir John Gifford ........................................................... 11 Sir Thomas Gifford ................................................................. +Elizabeth de Missenden ................................................................. 12 Roger Gifford ....................................................................... +Isabel Stretle or Stretele ....................................................................... 13 Thomas Gifford ............................................................................ . +Eleanor Vaux ............................................................................ . 14 John Gifford 1431 - 1506 ............................................................................ ....... +Agnes Winslow ............................................................................ ....... 15 Thomas Gifford - 1511 ............................................................................ ............. +Joan Langston ............................................................................ .............. 16 Amy Gifford - 1519 ............................................................................ .................... +Richard Samwell 1494 - ............................................................................ .................... 17 Susanna Samwell 1511 - 1552 ............................................................................ .......................... +Peter Edwards 1516 - 1552 ............................................................................ .......................... 18 Edward Edwards 1537 - 1591 ............................................................................ ................................ +Ursula Coles ............................................................................ ................................ 19 Margaret Edwards ............................................................................ ...................................... +Henry Freeman ............................................................................ ...................................... 20 Alice Freeman - 1664/65 ............................................................................ ............................................ +John Thompson - 1627 ............................................................................ ...................................... *2nd Husband of Alice Freeman: ............................................................................ ............................................ +Robert Parke 1580 - 1663/64