I believe that this Robert WESTLAKE married my Alice HALLOCK. She would have been wife #2 and NOT the mother of these children, tho it's possible she was mother of the youngest. This is from the 1870 Luzerne Co census, Scranton. Westlake Robert 37 Works in Planing Mill (?) b. England Alice 31 Keeping house b. Penna Luann/Susan? 23 At home b. Michigan Fannie 20 (illegible) b. Mich Willis 17 Lace maker b. Mich Robt 14 b. Penna Ann Eliza 6 Attend School b. Penna Robert remarried 1876 to wife #3. Her name was Mary Jane HARRISON. They had no children. I do not have a death date for Alice, but would guess she is buried in Scranton. I also think that Robert is listed here as being 10 years younger than he really was. I do believe all are Robert's children. Debbie