Found your family.. This family had the only James.. I can send the image as an attachment if you want it. Hope this helps, Cyd Rawls Pennsylvania, DAUPHIN, HALIFAX TWP       Series: M593, Roll: 1334, Page: 87   CHUBB, Henry, 52yrs b.PA CHUBB, Mary 48yrs b.PA CHUBB, Charles 22yrs b.PA CHUBB, Isaac 21yrs b.PA CHUBB, James 6yrs b.PA Here are the other Chubb families in 1870 in Halifax: CHUBB HENRY 52 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB HENRY 57 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB HENRY 74 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB HIRAM 25 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB JACOB 57 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB JANE 17 F W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB JOHN 39 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB JOHN 77 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB SAMUEL H 36 M W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870 CHUBB SARAH 42 F W PA PA DAUPHIN HALIFAX TWP 1870