Thanks to help of an Internet friend, I have some new names that are associated with my Charles L. Butterfield and his wife, Alvira/Elvira Diane Shirtliff. Elvira had a sister Elizabeth who married Henry Carter. Elizabeth died 5 July 1911 in Summerhill and is buried in Denny Cemetery. I have her obit but it doesn't give me any information on her parents. They also had a brother and sister living in Erie (no names). Are there any descendants of their kids? William Carter of Norrisville (1911), Mrs. G. W. Cole of Hayfield, Mrs. Grant Snyder of Butler Co., PA, and Ms. Jessie Brookhouser of Parkers Landing, PA. Any leads would be greatly appreciated. -- ********************************* Patricia Butterfield Vedner Conneautville, PA 16406 http://www.toolcity.net/~vedner Conneaut Valley Area Historical Society 1925 Main Street, Conneautville, PA 16406 Open 12-2:00 on Saturdays - Come visit us. http://www.granniesworld.com