Barb, My grandfather's eldest sister married John Carner Critchlow. Were your Critchlows from the Butler area? Did they leave the area? What is the time period for George W. and Mary E. It might make it easier to find them. The courthouse death registration book has a Lucinda J. Critchlow, age 58, married, born Butler Co., died after 10 month paralysis at Dixmont on 7-6-1900 and was buried there the next day. At Prospect, Franklin Township in the 1900 Butler County Census a Lucinda was shown, born May 1843 in Pa., age 57, married 20 years, had three children, all living, wife of John, born April 1848 in Pa., age 52, bricklayer, married 20 years, rents home. John's mother Elizabeth was living with them, born September 1824 in Pa., age 75, widow, had 6 children, five living. Happy Researching, Glee