hi everyone i'm hoping that some very nice person could lookup WM DOUGHERTY age 31 PA wife KATHRYN (KATE) age 30 PA son WM Jr age 12 PA son JOHN (JACK) age about 10 PA dgt FLORENCE (DOLLY) age about 8 PA they were possibly living with WM RUTLEDGE age 50 PA wife ANNA age 52 Ireland thank you all kathy Researching; DOUGHERTY, MACDONALD, SHUTT, PASZOTTA, BRENNAN, MCLAUGHLIN, GORDON, SHEPHARD, BAER, in Ireland, Pennsylvania or Delaware RENZ, VOLLMER (FULLMER), SCHUMACHER (SHOEMAKER) in Germany, Ohio or Indiana