I did an Ancestry.com search for you for both Christian and Carl as given names. I'm not sure whether they have Ohio indexed, so this isn't absolute, but the only one I found (using soundex) in 1840 in the whole US was: KLINDIST, CHRISTIAN State: PA Year: 1840 County: York County Township: N Codorus Page: 081 Database: PA 1840 Federal Census Index His neighbors were Adam Klindinst, Jacob Mummert, Daniel Clatfelter, John Chance, and John Kline. The family consisted of one male child, one female child, two adult males and one adult female. I don't have access to Pickaway marriage records, sorry. Len