Joe, I found the following GAY marriages in the book, "Marriage Records, Pickaway Co.,OH 1810-1862" published by the Pickaway County Historical Society. I noticed that there are 2 entries for Sarah HEDGES marrying Isaac & Joshua GAY on May 11th in 1834 & 1838, so you may need to have someone check the actual court records to see if this a mistake. 1. Benjamin F. m. 30 Nov 1856 Eliza KING by unknown 2. Elizabeth m. 21 Jul 1834 William REED Jr. by (blank) 3. Isaac m. 11 May 1838 Sarah HEDGES by Alex McClean JP 4. James m. 27 May 1832 Pamela ROSS by John Coons Rev. 5. John Jr. m. 30 May 1825 Margaret BRADY by (blank) 6. Joseph m. 26 Aug 1829 Sarah EVANS by (blank) 7. Joshua m. 11 May 1834 Sarah HEDGES by Alex McClean JP 8. Joshua m. 15 Jul 1830 Mary BARTLEY by David Holderman JP 9. William m. 16 Jul 1833 Mary EVANS by (blank) Note: (Blank) "By" Column presumes that no return was received by the County. Hope this helps Cathy