OK Ken - I finally figured this out several weeks ago. It is muddy water. James Morton Dye (son of John and Mary Hixon Dye) born 3-17-1782 Fairfax Co., Virginia died 3-25-1827 Jackson Township, Monroe Co., Ohio (Unity Cemetery, Perry Township wed abt 1800 in Fairfax Co., Virginia Elizabeth Dye(daughter of Daniel and Abigail Hutcherson Dye Sr.) born 7-18-1782 Prince William Co., Virginia died 3-19-1856 Perry Township, Monroe Co., Ohio(Unity Cemetery, Perry Township Children were George W., John R., Daniel, Mary, Sarah, James, Nancy, Francis, Susanna, Abigail, Elam, Elizabeth and Amelia. John R. Dye(son of James Morton and Elizabeth Dye Dye) born abt 1803 Alexandria, Virginia died 9-21-1844 Monroe Co., Ohio wed 9-3-1826 Monroe Co. Ohio Ary Ridgeway (daughter of Benjamin and Mary Ann Riggs Ridgeway) born 11-13-1804 Ohio died 2-15-1890 Monroe Co., Ohio Children were Bazel Riggs, Isaac, Benjamin, Joshua, Amos, Elam and Mahlon Benjamin Ridgeway - no dates(probably Unity Cemetery but no stones) Mary Ann Riggs 1771-1855 Mahlon and Sarah Elizabeth States Dye's daughter Alice is what I found in the census. She was 1 year old in 1860. That is all I know. I found no marriage for her in Belmont, Monroe or Washington Co., Ohio. I think they left the county, but haven't traced them yet. Too much else to do. All of the information on the above families came from Eleanor Phillips a descendant of the James and Elizabeth Dye line. Also what I could find in the Fedorchak and various county published genealogy books. Next little muddy water. Henry B. States(son of Archibald and Sarah Brewer States) born 12-25-1825 Westmoreland Co., PA died 9-15-1859 Monroe Co., Ohio(buried Drum Cemetery, Wayne Township, Monroe Co., Ohio) wed January 2, 1847 Monroe Co., Ohio Mary Margaret Drum (daughter of Jacob and Sarah Noffsinger Drum) born 1-2-1831 Ohio died 4-9-1882 Jericho, Benton Township, Monroe Co., Ohio (buried Jericho cemetery) Henry and Mary Margaret States had Francis (abt 1848), Sarah Elizabeth (abt 1850), Mary Ellen (abt 1854) and Archibald (June 1857). After Henry's death, Mary Margaret Drum States married abt 1860 Samuel Hamilton Cline born 8-5-1819 Benton Township, Monroe Co., Ohio died 8-6-1905 Benton Township, Monroe Co., Ohio (Jericho Cemetery) Samuel and Mary Margaret Drum States Cline had the following children: Samuel, James Hamilton, Louisa May, Charles Fegan and Christian Sanders. Now before Samuel married Mary Margaret Drum States, he was married to Mary Katherine States (daughter of Archibald and Sarah Brewer States) born 4-15-1833 Westmoreland Co. PA died 9-19-1859 Monroe Co., Ohio(buried Jericho Cemetery) Samuel and Mary Katherine Cline had one child Archibald, born 1858 and died 3-25-1859. As you can see, Samuel married sister-in-laws. It really had me going for a while, but answered questions and at least I didn't have to trace the Mary Katherine line anymore. In our family records it is spelled Mary Catherine States. I am sourcing what I can with the books, films, etc. but a lot of the history I have was given to me out of Bibles up to 45 years ago and old letters. My mother, when she was helping me get things straight while I raised a family, very carefully copied the letters and I am afraid destroyed some. She is a perfectionist and I am sure checked and rechecked the information. They were all from family members who took the time to check with other of their relatives and get the information back to me. Today, I give a family a list I need filled out to get me up to date and I never see it again. Enough for now. Anything you have bringing any of these families down to the present would be appreciated as I tend to bring all my grandparents children as far forward as I can. We also have kept tract of parents, grandparents, etc. as far as we could go so that the information would never be lost. Jerilyn PS If anyone reading this sees any errors or can add to the information, please feel free to contact me.