Kathy, I have Nathaniel Caldwell Guthrie 4 Apr 1831, d. 4 Jul 1923 m. Ruth Rose on 2 Feb 1854 in Harrison co., Ohio.(Ruth d/Amos Rose b 1831 in Pa , d.1856and Eliz Garner b. before 1831 in Harrison co., Ohio. ) Amos was s/Robt and Sarah Sophia Rose married in1796, according to Tom ([email protected] 2nd wife of Nathaniel was Nancy Garner m. 14 Apr 1857, d. 21 May 1859. 3rd wife of Nathaniel was Sarah Adelaide Edney m. 17 Nov 1866, lived near Deersville, Oh., in Harrison co. (Sarah was 10th child of Rbt and Mary Pittis Edney of England. Generations: 1 Robert Guthrie 1752-1815 m.Jane Caldwell 1752-1815 2 James Cunningham Guthrie 1798-1864 m.Eliz Auld 1821-? 3 Nathaniel Caldwell 1831-1923 m. Ruth...Nancy and Sarah... Don Wagner, New Philadelhia, Oh.