Thanks, Sandi!! Still don't know if I'll ever find the answer. David's obit said he was from Augusta Co., VA, so I decided to check Chalkey's. I think I found Frederick but not David. Frederick appears to be the son of Frederick. There is a will for old Frederick and young Frederick is a minor, and that fits with the ages. Also, named in the will is Betsy Steele, wife of William Steele. Interestingly, she is named in Hardesty's and it states they (Steeles) came here in 1815. This would make young Frederick and Betsy Steele siblings. Still doesn't help me prove that David was young Frederick's son....but who knows? May find it one day. Henny