Sandi, Thanks for the info. My dad (now deceased) left his papers with me and one of them said William was born in SC and Elizabeth in NC- but no dates. I found in the 1880 Census of Gallia Co., Lewis Garlic says his father was born in SC and his mother in NC (although the letters were faded and hard to read). Am glad to have their marriage date and place, and the children. Do you know where they are buried?. The "Cemeteries of Guyan TWP...." book shows Lewis and Nancy Garlic buried in the Garlic Cemetery. Wonder if William and Elizabeth are there too? Also, wonder when they arrived in Gallia Co.