Bob, Found them in 1900 census living in 5-wd Cleveland. Family visit 57 HILAND, Robert, Head, Sept 1855, 44, married 5 yrs, b. Wisconsin, Wisconsin, Wisconsin, Real Estate, rents house Mabel B. wife, Sept 1873, 26, 2 children / 2 living, b. OH, OH, OH Margaret E, daughter, Aug 1895, 4, b. OH Robert M, son, Dec 1899, 5/12, b. OH Family visit 58 JOHNSTON, James, Head, Apr 1844, 56, married 36 yrs, b. IRE, immigrated 1854, watchman, rents house Margaret, wife, Apr 1844, 56, 3 children / 3 living, b. IRE, immigrated 1853 Could this possibly be them in 1870 in 9-wd Cleveland? JOHNSON, James, 29, works in pipe factory, b. IRE Margaret, 28, keeping house, b. IRE Amanda, 2, b. PA ~~~ David, 21, works in pipe factory, b. ENG If this is them, they may possibly have lived in PA in 1860 census.