Is there a possibility that your Tuttle family originally came from Brooklyn to Ohio? My ggrandmother lived in Brooklyn until 1883. She was 12 when her family moved to Philadelphia, however she had a close friend who was a Tuttle. Oddly, by the mid 1890s, her sister Emma Rawlins Issel moved with her husband Carl Issel to Cleveland. Emma's mother, Maria Heck Rawlins Pfeiff also joined them. I couldn' t help wondering if there was some family connection between your Tuttle family and my Rawlins line,as the name is so unusual. It is a very "long shot" but I couldn't help asking. Bev W.