Audra: The present courthouse was erected in 1889; there was a different courthouse previous to that. See the following link for courthouse history: http://www.butlercountyprobatecourt.org/index.cfm?page=virtualTour You are correct on both the location of the cemetery and where the records are located. I believe a church representative is the only person allowed to work with the records so you might want to do that by mail. The smallish cemetery of St. Mary's is located on the east side of Pleasant Avenue and is not very noticeable from the street; keep a sharp eye to your left once you pass St. Clair Avenue while heading south or you will miss the entrance. Diane Beaty Before us lies a new day, and in the distance a new world, ours to create by the strength of our faith.