You're right, Ann. Ann Dill could have been the mother of Charles. Recently I saw something on TV stating that years ago, women in their 50s were still having children. I've had a suspicion all along, though, that Margaret could have had an illegitimate child but I haven't been able to confirm that yet. More later, Barbara in Indiana Ann Trimmer <ann@trimmer.net> wrote: Why couldn't Ann Dill be the mother of Charles? Lots of women have given birth at the age of 48. It is always possible however, that Margaret was the unwed mother of Charles who was then adopted by Ann and then listed as a son. I have seen that happen too. ==== OHBUTLER Mailing List ==== To SUBSCRIBE or UNSUBSCRIBE: Send a message to: OHBUTLER-L-request@rootsweb.com or OHBUTLER-D-request@rootsweb.com Put SUBSCRIBE or UNSUBSCRIBE (whichever you want to do)