Judy, I didn't find a Robert ROSE, father of Carrie. The one I found had a daughter Edith and he's only 34 yrs. old. Is that the one you want? Marilyn in Ohio --------------original message-------------- In a message dated 05/12/04 5:22:32 PM Eastern Daylight Time, pjhanke@valleytel.net writes: << I'm beginning to think that Bertha was married to someone else. I would like to see the Robert Rose father of Carrie because I'm related to the Roses also. Thanks for trying. My memory may not be accurate in this case. Judy Hanke >>