-- [ From: Richard Frisbie * EMC.Ver #2.5.02 ] -- Dear Mary C. VanAlstyne and Listmembers, Mostly - I agree with what has been posted, and in some places it isn't up to me to agree or disagree. However, please don't shoot the messenger. I related a quote from a speaker at an historians meeting - not my feelings. And, as far as the "consensus of opinion" goes about "no order forbidding them to so do" - it was stated as a local law prohibiting municipal historians (in New York State) for doing genealogical research on anyone's behalf. I reported it because it surprised me too - I hadn't heard of it either. About historians themselves - well-said Mary! Truly, they usually have no salary, no budget, demands from all levels for their very limited time, and a genuine love of history -- AND - my respect. Richard