Perhaps a clue from the 1888-1889 Ithaca Directory: Edward Doyle of Doyle and Cleary 23 E. State St., Ithaca I've no idea what was at that location in the late 1880s but this might give you an avenue for further research. All the other Doyles were residing at 128 W. State St. in the same Directory. Happy Hunting! Joyce, Raleigh, NC