HI Steve I used t go to St Matthias and so did my kids and the address on that was 58-15 Catalapa Ave It sounds like your address was more towards Fresh Pond Rd .Maybe u can look it up or call the Ridgewood Times Newspapers they may be able to help u Peter Geis Funeral home was 57-34 Catalapa Ave cor of Onderdonk Ave This goes back to 1970 when I had moved out of Ridgewood .Sure hope this helps some . Best Wishes Julie ---- from Ocala,Florida now