Thank You Karl I don't normally say much or post to this board, but in this case Kim was doing what she thought was the right thing, ask a question and that's how you knock down walls in genealogy is by asking a question, the person asking the question may not know what or how to ask, but does the best they can to gain the information they need to further there research so they can move on to the next question.. So Kim.. Keep asking your question's as there are no stupid or half asked questions in Geneology.Just Research. Ron B ----- Original Message ----- From: Karl MacEachron <[email protected]> Date: Tuesday, February 22, 2005 9:42 am Subject: [NYOnonda] Who Do You Think > On the 21st, a lister named 'Kim' asked: > Can anyone tell me if the Onondaga County Public Library in > Syracuse has New > York State censuses (1855, 1865, 1875, etc.) for counties OTHER THAN > Onondaga? > > A reply was sent by Carl Hommel criticizing Kim by saying the > question was poorly asked. > > F8rst, I understood Kim very well and thought her question was a > good one. > Next, If a degree in English is required to ask questions on this > list, please let me know and I > will unsubscribe immediately. > > And, Carl who do you think you are taking someone to task like > that! Are you so perfect that you > can throw stones? > > My apologies if this is out of line but I felt Carl was rude and > crude. > > Karl MacEachron > Fresno CA > > >