This is a family that a daughter, Abby BENTLEY married James M. SHEPARD And this is a family that SARAH GRAVES SHEPARD boarded with in The 1870 census - 1850 Census - pg 42 - date taken 11 Sep 1850 Evans, Erie, New York BENTLEY Dwelling - 332 Family 336 Name - William Age - 33 [born 1814] Sex - m Color - w Occupation - Sawyer Place of birth - New York Name - Rebecca M. Age - 30 [born 1820] Sex - f Color - w Place of birth - New York Name - Phoebe A. Age - 12 [born 1838] Sex - f Color - w Place of birth - New York Name - ABBE J. [ours] Age - 10 [born 1840] Sex - f Color - w Place of birth - New York Name - David Age - 7 [born 1843] Sex - m Color - w Place of birth- New York Next page - pg 43 Name - Francis Age - 6 [born 1844] Sex- m Color - w Place of birth - New York Name - Cornelia Age - 3 [ born 1847] Sex - f Color - w Place of birth - New York Name - William H. [looks like H] Age - 1 [ born 1849] Sex - m Color - w Place of birth - New York On this same page 43 is Mathias SHEPARD - DWELLING 338 - so they were all neighbors- Thank you, Wilma Fleming Haynes wilmahaynes@direcway.com or wilmahaynes@direcpc.com