Charles D. Shaver (Shaffer) was located on the 1880 Gallatin, Colombia Co., NY federal census, page 186D. He was 45, born in NY. Mary C., wife, was 44. Eliza M., daughter, 18. Ethna A. (I have her as Eva), daughter, was 15. Mary E., daughter, was 11. Charles J., son, was 8. Ward D., son, was 5. Peter S., son, was 2. Wife Mary was a Finger, daughter of John (Johannes) Finger and Eliza Freiz. Shirley Maynard