Posted on: Columbia County NY. Query Forum Reply Here: http://cgi.rootsweb.com/~genbbs/genbbs.cgi/USA/NY/Columbia/11848 Surname: Hotaling, Minshell, Tobias, Brewer ------------------------- Has anyone ever heard of Harry HOTALING from Valatie? I am looking for Caroline MINSHELL (orphan) who was living with Harry HOTALING and his wife (may be Nora??) according to the 1920 Kinderhook census for Valatie Village - she is listed as their 13 yr old niece. Caroline is also mentioned in probate records as being with an Elias HOTALING in 1917. Please let me know if these names sound familiar. Thank you for your help