Thanks to everyone who has responded to my plea for help. After studying many GenForum messages and census records all day again, I believe that the Eliza Defiat shown on the 1860 Peru census shown with James Keone and Sophrona is Sophrona's sister, both daughters of Albert Defayette and Marie Hebert. I know she married Nathan Carpenter about 1861-1862 because their daughter's birth is in the Assumption of Mary of Redford. It is shown as Ann Lizzy Carpenter b. 8/22/1862. Problem is I can't find their marriage, nor can I locate them in 1870. I think they may have moved to Michigan by 1870 because I located a Nathan and Eliza there, but with no children. Karen