Hi Linda, I will dig out the divorce decree for Robert Carroll and Lillian Duley. But his date of birth is Apr 25, 1918. Is this your line? Sande Marriage 1 Robert CARROLL b: 25 Apr 1918 in Elmira, Chemung, New York Change Date: 13 Sep 2003 Children Nancy Ann CARROLL b: 22 Sep 1939 in Dannemora, Clinton, New York