Dear Lauren, A 1893 Brooklyn Almanac places the rectory at 927 Herkimer and the church at Fulton St. near Ralph Ave. It is described as German R. C. In my 1976 Brooklyn street guide I can't find any mention of St. Benedict's Ok, here's why, according to http://mysite.verizon.net/timdesmond/files/churches.htm St. Benedict (German) [1853; Closed 1973] - Fulton & Ralph {25th ward} Good luck with your search - Anne Brown .