Hello Kelly: I checked The Saint Paul's Baptism and marriage records between 1839 and 1857 and could not find Charles Fagan, Matthew Fagan or his wife Catherine. Also checked Fagan in Tombstones of the Irish Born - Cemetery of the Holy Cross, Flatbush, Brooklyn which was established in 1849 according to Stiles the Brooklyn Historian. In the Tombstone book I found at page 32: FAGAN Catherine B. 4/31/1891, 68, Castlematyr, Cork Her sister Abagail Barry, 3/26/1897, 72 I don't know if this helps you, but this is how I found a sister of my GGF Matthew Corrigan that I didn't know about. Pauline Salmon San Diego Your info on 7/7/14 > > Charles Fagan b 1857 > 1875 census Brooklyn > Father Matthew > Mother "Catherine" might be her chosen name > Dates for father MF correct