Thanks everyone for all the information...I still haven't quite figured it out. The marriage was between Edward Mahoney and Anna Buckley (lis. was issued as Manhattan) on March 3, 1889. the person performing the marriage was Frederic Janes (at least it looks like a "J", it is definitely not a "G") and the residence of the Clergyman was 337 Fourth Avenue. The bride lived at 589 Third Ave in Manhattan around the time of her marriage. When I put 337 Fourth Avenue in Mapquest, I get Brooklyn, NY. I am not familiar with NYC. I do know, that in Philly, some street names have been changed since 1889, and was also wondering if this could be the case. I know she was Catholic. Original Message: > Hi Everyone, > > I just received a Certificate of Marriage for one of my Buckley family > members. The clergyman's residence is listed at 337 Fourth Avenue in NYC. > I looked at the archdiocese website and don't see a church for that > address (unless I missed it.) Online today at that address it is listed > as the NY Etching Club. Would anyone know if there used to be a church > there? I would assume it to be a Catholic Church. If not, I was > wondering if my other "clue", might indicate that it wasn't. Under > Witnesses (not person performing the ceremony) to the Marriage it listes > "J. Carpenter (Evangelist)". > > Any help would be greatly appreciated. > > Thanks, > Susan > ====NY-Irish