Hi Jared Was hoping you were researching these folks. I did see the Middleton Outlook page (John Parker/Phil Vogler) showing that 10 "unnamed" children were indicated for George=Eliza so was hoping you might have the other 2 children, since I only have 8. As far as the Hannah-Harriet situation, I am showing 11 different sources identifying her as Hannah and this 12th source (newspaper account) being the only one showing her as Harriet. Could be a typo or a mistranscription at the site that you sent me to. But haven't ruled that 100% out as of yet. George CHARLTON=Hannah (nee) CHUTE married (their 2nd marriages) rather late in life. No children. He being 69 at the time and Hannah being 57. He doing so after he was married to Eliza ROBINSON for 41 years. Eliza dying 5 years before George remarried to Hannah. I'm not sure George would have time for a 3rd wife, but you never know. George died 10 years after he married Hannah. I'm more inclined to think there was just Eliza and Hannah as his wives and that "Harriet" may have been a mistranscription or a typo at that site and should have said "Hannah." However, I must admit that I have seen Harriet and Hannah interchanged in other families I study. All the info that I have on John Henry BARTEAUX (Hannah CHUTE's 1st husband) indicates that her name was Hannah as well. Thanks for your help, Jared Richard Richard Hardwick (Researching direct lines in Nova Scotia and New England - HARDWICK, ARMSTRONG, BARTEAUX, SPURR, HENDERSON, BLACKMAR, MARSH) RiHardwick@comcast.net ----- Original Message ----- From: "Jared Handspicker" <jedh@jedh.com> To: "Richard Hardwick" <RiHardwick@comcast.net> Cc: <jedh@jedh.com>; "David Hue" <david.hue@ns.sympatico.ca>; <nova-scotia-l@rootsweb.com> Sent: Friday, August 10, 2007 3:01 AM Subject: Re: [NS-L] Eliza Robinson or Robertson > Hello Richard, > > This is not a line of mine, was merely offering additional reasoning for > the choice of Robinson vs. Robertson. The information provided was, as > indicated, found in an online "edition" of "The Outlook" from 1903, and on > the Nova Scotia Vital Records site. > > Surely, Thomas Robinson Charlton and Robinson Thomas Charlton are one and > the same person, perhaps he would go by "Robinson" to be distinguished > from another Thomas? As for Harriet/Hannah, in some cases, could be same > person, but I've also run across instances where that thinking led to > serious confusion, and was later proved to be two separate wives, with two > different "batches" of children. > > Just my 2 cents. > > Jared > >> Hi Jared >> >> Thank you. >> >> To add a few more folks to the mix - >> >> (1) The widow of John Henry BARTEAUX (I show) was Hannah Maria CHUTE. Is >> it >> Hannah or Harriet? You show Harriet. I show Hannah. Several of my >> sources >> show Hannah. Maybe one and same? >> >> (2) I am showing George William CHARLTON's mother as Catherine GARDNER >> >> (3) I am showing Robinson Thomas CHARLTON as Thomas Robinson CHARLTON. >> Probably not an issue other than the fact that (in the son) the Robinson >> name pops up again giving rise to the fact that Eliza was probably a >> ROBINSON. >> >> (4) I have Thomas Robinson (or Robinson Thomas) also married to Rose >> CHUTE >> as well as Susan R UNKNOWN. >> >> >> ******************* >> Jared, in addition to Hannah vs Harriet question above, would you happen >> to >> have Thomas ROBINSON's wife's name (Thomas, father of Eliza ROBINSON)? >> >> I am only showing 8 children of George CHARLTON=Eliza ROBINSON - and you >> indicate 10. Might you have the 10 names so I can see who I am missing? >> >> Thanks much >> >> Richard >> >> >> >> ----- Original Message ----- >> From: "Jared Handspicker" <jedh@jedh.com> >> To: "Richard Hardwick" <RiHardwick@comcast.net> >> Cc: "David Hue" <david.hue@ns.sympatico.ca>; <nova-scotia-l@rootsweb.com> >> Sent: Thursday, August 09, 2007 12:50 PM >> Subject: Re: [NS-L] Eliza Robinson or Robertson >> >> >>> --- >>> From "The Outlook", Middleton, Annapolis, published 1903: >>> >>> http://www.rootsweb.com/~canbrnep/vitstatom1903.htm >>> >>> Charlton, George W., died at Williamston, Mon last, b. Arlington, Anna. >>> Co., 79 years s/o Henry Charlton ; m1. Eliza Robinson d/o Thomas >>> Robinson >>> [10 chnn]; m2. Harriet wid/o John H. Barteaux, Nictaux. [25 Sept 1903 >>> obituary]. >>> >>> --- >>> >>> NS VR would appear to confirm ROBINSON with the following death record: >>> >>> Robinson Thomas Charlton, d. 03-Jun-1938, at South Williamston, >>> Annapolis >>> Co, NS >>> b. 02-Dec-1863, NS, married to Susan. Son of George W. Charlton and >>> Eliza >>> Robinson, both born NS. >>> Robinson was buried Nictaux Plains, on 06-Jun-1938. The informant on his >>> record was listed as his daughter, Lucy ?Marisa? Charlton, Saint John, >>> NB. >>> >>> --- >>> >>> Jared >>>> Hi David >>>> >>>> I have her as Elizabeth ROBINSON. But as you know, there have been >>>> many >>>> instances where ROBINSONs and ROBERTSONs have been interchanged with >>>> one >>>> another. Husband George CHARLTON and Elizabeth had a son Thomas >>>> Robinson >>>> CHARLTON so maybe this is an indication for ROBINSON? Unfortunately, I >>>> do >>>> not have her parents which would be the clincher. >>>> >>>> Vernon Spurr (now deceased), in his SPURR Genealogy, has her as >>>> Elizabeth >>>> ROBINSON. Vernon was the consummate researcher. >>>> >>>> Richard Hardwick >>>> >>>> (Researching direct lines in Nova Scotia and New England - HARDWICK, >>>> ARMSTRONG, BARTEAUX, SPURR, HENDERSON, BLACKMAR, MARSH) >>>> RiHardwick@comcast.net >>>> >>>> ----- Original Message ----- >>>> From: "David Hue" <david.hue@ns.sympatico.ca> >>>> To: "NOVA-SCOTIA-L" <NOVA-SCOTIA-L@rootsweb.com> >>>> Sent: Thursday, August 09, 2007 9:08 AM >>>> Subject: [NS-L] Eliza Robinson or Robertson >>>> >>>> >>>>> Hello everyone, >>>>> Is Eliza, a Robinson or Robertson? married to George >>>>> William >>>>> Charlton 15 Feb 1847. Records are found in Annapolis Township Book. >>>>> Book >>>>> states Robinson but I have Robertson. Could someone confirm one way or >>>>> the >>>>> other. >>>>> >>>>> Regards >>>>> Dave in Shubenacadie >>>>> No virus found in this outgoing message. >>>>> Checked by AVG Free Edition. >>>>> Version: 7.5.476 / Virus Database: 269.11.10/943 - Release Date: >>>>> 8/8/2007 >>>>> 5:38 PM >>>>> >>>>> ---------------------------------------- >>>>> Basic List Commands: >>>>> >>>>> 1. To post to the list >>>>> Send a message to: >>>>> NOVA-SCOTIA-L@rootsweb.com >>>>> >>>>> 2. How to unsubscribe >>>>> a. List mode: Send a message to NOVA-SCOTIA-L- >>>>> request@rootsweb.com that contains only the word >>>>> unsubscribe >>>>> >>>>> b. Digest mode: Send a message to NOVA-SCOTIA-D- >>>>> request@rootsweb.com that contains only the word >>>>> unsubscribe >>>>> >>>>> 3. How to subscribe >>>>> Send an email containing only the word >>>>> subscribe >>>>> to NOVA-SCOTIA-L-request@rootsweb.com >>>>> >>>>> 4. How to change to Digest mode >>>>> a. Unsubscribe from List mode (2.a. above) >>>>> b. Subscribe to Digest mode >>>>> Send an email containing only the word >>>>> subscribe >>>>> to NOVA-SCOTIA-D-request@rootsweb.com >>>>> ------------------------------- >>>>> To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to >>>>> NOVA-SCOTIA-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without >>>>> the >>>>> quotes in the subject and the body of the message >>>> >>>> ---------------------------------------- >>>> Basic List Commands: >>>> >>>> 1. To post to the list >>>> Send a message to: >>>> NOVA-SCOTIA-L@rootsweb.com >>>> >>>> 2. How to unsubscribe >>>> a. List mode: Send a message to NOVA-SCOTIA-L- >>>> request@rootsweb.com that contains only the word >>>> unsubscribe >>>> >>>> b. Digest mode: Send a message to NOVA-SCOTIA-D- >>>> request@rootsweb.com that contains only the word >>>> unsubscribe >>>> >>>> 3. How to subscribe >>>> Send an email containing only the word >>>> subscribe >>>> to NOVA-SCOTIA-L-request@rootsweb.com >>>> >>>> 4. How to change to Digest mode >>>> a. Unsubscribe from List mode (2.a. above) >>>> b. Subscribe to Digest mode >>>> Send an email containing only the word >>>> subscribe >>>> to NOVA-SCOTIA-D-request@rootsweb.com >>>> ------------------------------- >>>> To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to >>>> NOVA-SCOTIA-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without >>>> the >>>> quotes in the subject and the body of the message >>>> >>> >>> >>> ------------------------ >>> Jared "Jed" Handspicker >>> jedh@jedh.com >>> >>> >> > > > ------------------------ > Jared "Jed" Handspicker > jedh@jedh.com > >